They Want Women to Collect Their Abortion Remains in a Catch Kit.

Congress has new ideas for regulating abortion pills.
avatar
Posted on Nov 13, 2026 by
Kelly Carmichael
10 mins read 

Photo by Guido Hofmann on Unsplash

Imagine you're a woman experiencing one of the most physically and emotionally difficult moments of your life. You're ending an early pregnancy at home using medication prescribed by a healthcare provider.

You've prepared yourself for the bleeding, cramping, and uncertainty that can accompany the process. You want privacy, medical guidance, and perhaps someone you trust nearby.

What you probably don't expect is a government-mandated collection kit with instructions for retrieving biological material from your toilet, separating it into specially labeled biohazard containers, and transporting it to a medical facility.

Yet that's precisely the kind of system some members of Congress are proposing.

Welcome to the barbaric world of Catch Kits.

And before you decide I've stumbled across another bizarre conspiracy theory, let me assure you that this one comes directly from the United States Congress.

Congratulations. Congress Has Invented the Abortion Catch Kit.

On November 5, 2026, Republican Representative Sheri Biggs of South Carolina introduced H.R. 10954, a piece of federal legislation officially titled the Don't Flush Babies Act. Republican Representative Michael Cloud of Texas joined her as a cosponsor.

Yes, that's the actual name.

The proposed law would require healthcare providers who prescribe or dispense abortion medication to supply patients with something called a Catch Kit.

And these aren't ordinary medical supplies.

According to the legislation, each kit would contain two brightly colored, leak-resistant biohazard containers. One would be labeled "Human Fetal Remains." The other would be labeled "Solid Medical Waste."

The kit would also include instructions for collecting, containing, transporting, and returning the biological material expelled during a medication abortion.

The proposed system calls for that material to be returned in person, either by the patient or someone authorized to act on her behalf. Mailing it back would be prohibited.

Healthcare providers would then be responsible for arranging burial or cremation of the fetal remains and appropriate disposal of the remaining waste.

I don't know about you, but when I first encountered this proposal, I had to read it several times. We're talking about lawmakers attempting to regulate what happens inside a woman's bathroom during a private medical procedure.

And somehow, they've managed to package the entire concept as a public-health initiative.

Apparently, America's Toilets Have Become a National Emergency

The stated justification for the legislation involves environmental protection, plumbing damage, and the disposal of fetal remains.

According to the bill's findings, improperly discarded pregnancy tissue and related medical waste may cause plumbing blockages or environmental contamination.

Now, I'm certainly in favor of clean drinking water. I'm also enthusiastic about functioning plumbing. Anyone who's ever dealt with a backed-up sewer line probably shares that sentiment.

But I have a few questions.

Where is the compelling scientific evidence demonstrating that medication abortions are creating a widespread sewage emergency? How significant is the alleged environmental risk compared with other substances routinely entering wastewater systems? And why would the proposed solution require women to collect biological material from their own bodies?

These aren't unreasonable questions. They're exactly the questions we should be asking whenever lawmakers propose sweeping new requirements in the name of protecting public health.

The Guttmacher Institute, which researches reproductive health policy, has challenged the scientific foundation of similar environmental claims. Its analysis describes how abortion opponents have increasingly used wastewater concerns to justify restrictions on medication abortion.

That doesn't mean environmental questions should never be investigated. If there is a legitimate hazard, researchers should examine it and regulators should address it.

But an environmental claim isn't automatically scientific evidence simply because somebody introduces it into a congressional bill.

And the burden of proof should become considerably higher when the proposed remedy involves regulating what women do in their bathrooms.

Wait Until You See the Warning Label

If the collection containers aren't startling enough, the legislation also proposes a special warning label for abortion medication.

The packaging would display a prominent warning telling patients not to flush fetal remains or solid medical waste. But Congress apparently doesn't believe words alone are sufficient.

The bill specifies that the packaging must include an illustration of a fetus at ten weeks of gestation, with recognizable anatomical features, positioned beside an image of a toilet. Both images would appear inside the familiar red prohibition symbol.

Imagine that for a moment. A federally mandated illustration of a fetus and a toilet, complete with a red slash, printed directly on abortion medication packaging.

Supporters might argue that the image communicates their concerns about fetal dignity and disposal practices.

Critics could reasonably question whether its purpose is medical education, emotional persuasion, or both. What interests me is the extraordinary level of detail.

Congress isn't merely proposing general standards for safe medication use. It's specifying the artwork, the container colors, the wording of the labels, and the procedures for transporting pregnancy tissue.

You have to wonder how we arrived at a point where federal lawmakers believe designing abortion-pill packaging is an appropriate use of their legislative authority.

This Didn't Start With One Congressman and a Plumbing Problem

The Catch Kit idea didn't suddenly materialize in November. Earlier this year, Republican Representative Mary Miller of Illinois introduced another federal proposal called the Clean Water for All Life Act.

That legislation sought to prohibit medication abortions without an in-person healthcare examination and additional requirements involving the collection and disposal of pregnancy-related medical waste.

Supporters argued that the measures would protect women, preserve fetal dignity, and prevent environmental contamination.

Critics saw something entirely different. They saw another way to restrict access to abortion medication without necessarily imposing a straightforward nationwide ban. Consider the practical implications.

Medication abortion can be provided through telehealth in jurisdictions where the practice is legal. That matters enormously to patients living in rural communities, people without reliable transportation, and women who cannot afford to take several days away from work.

Now introduce requirements involving in-person appointments, collection containers, and the physical return of biological material.

Suddenly, a process that might otherwise occur at home becomes entangled in transportation arrangements, medical-facility access, and complicated disposal procedures.

A woman who lives two hundred miles from the nearest available provider might face a particularly difficult situation. And while the November federal bill requires providers to receive returned material, its criminal penalties are directed at prescribers and dispensers who violate the kit requirements, not at women merely for failing to return tissue.

That distinction matters. But so does the possibility that healthcare professionals could decide the regulatory burden is simply too risky.

Sometimes access to medical care can be restricted without making the underlying procedure explicitly illegal. You just make providing it so complicated that fewer professionals are willing to participate.

And Then There's the Woman Who Miscarried

This is the part of the Catch Kit controversy that I find especially troubling.

In Wisconsin, lawmakers introduced legislation involving the collection and disposal of pregnancy tissue. The American Civil Liberties Union of Wisconsin warned that the proposal could affect women experiencing miscarriages as well as those undergoing medication abortions.

Think about the emotional implications.

Imagine a woman who has been trying desperately to become pregnant. Perhaps she's undergone fertility treatments. Perhaps she's already selected a name, told her family, or begun imagining the child she hopes to welcome.

Then she starts bleeding. She's frightened, devastated, and possibly experiencing severe pain. Her pregnancy is ending, and there may be nothing she can do to stop it.

Now imagine adding a government-directed procedure requiring her to collect the expelled pregnancy tissue and return it for disposal.

Does that sound compassionate? Does it sound medically necessary? Or does it sound like another bureaucratic requirement imposed on someone who is already suffering?

Supporters of fetal-remains legislation often emphasize the importance of treating pregnancy tissue with dignity. I understand that people hold deeply different beliefs about when life begins and how fetal remains should be handled.

But shouldn't compassion for the living patient also be part of that conversation? A woman experiencing a miscarriage isn't a waste-disposal contractor.

She's a human being undergoing a medical and potentially heartbreaking event.

And I have difficulty understanding why lawmakers would want to make that experience even more complicated.

The Government Doesn't Need Another Paper Trail

There's another provision in the November federal bill that deserves attention.

Healthcare providers would be required to obtain and retain a physical or electronic acknowledgment confirming that patients received their Catch Kits and accompanying instructions.

The documentation would also identify the nearest appropriate facility for returning the material and specify its approximate distance from the patient's address.

Now, to be fair, the legislation doesn't explicitly establish a national database of women who have abortions. Nor does it require patients to photograph what they collect.

But it would create additional documentation associated with a deeply personal medical procedure.

And that raises some interesting privacy questions.

Who would have access to these records? How long would they be retained? Under what circumstances could they be requested during legal proceedings? And what protections would prevent sensitive information from being misused?

These questions are especially important in a country where abortion laws vary dramatically from state to state. A medical record that seems routine in one jurisdiction could become the subject of controversy or litigation in another.

I'm not suggesting that every additional medical document automatically creates a surveillance system.

But I am suggesting that whenever government requires more documentation of private reproductive healthcare, the public deserves a clear explanation of why that information is necessary and how it will be protected.

Five Years in Prison Over an Abortion Kit?

Here's where the legislation becomes considerably more serious.

Under H.R. 10954, a person who prescribes or dispenses abortion medication without providing the required Catch Kit and documentation, or who tampers with a kit, could face imprisonment for up to five years.

The proposed fines range from $20,000 to $150,000 per offense, with imprisonment, fines, or both possible.

That's not a minor administrative penalty. Those are potentially life-altering consequences for healthcare professionals.

Imagine being a physician who provides reproductive healthcare in a politically contentious environment. You're already navigating complex medical regulations, changing state laws, and the possibility of litigation.

Now you're facing potential criminal penalties involving the distribution of collection containers and associated documentation.

Would every physician continue providing medication abortions under those circumstances? Probably not.

And that possibility illustrates why the practical consequences of legislation deserve as much attention as its stated intentions.

A law doesn't have to explicitly prohibit a treatment to discourage professionals from offering it. Sometimes all it takes is the threat of financial ruin or imprisonment.

The Strange New Politics of Environmental Protection

There's something fascinating about the way environmental arguments have entered the abortion debate.

For years, reproductive rights disputes centered on constitutional law, fetal development, religious beliefs, medical ethics, and the boundaries of government authority.

Now we're discussing wastewater treatment plants.

The Guttmacher Institute documented nine bills introduced across seven states in 2025 that used environmental arguments to target medication abortion.

Some proposals focused on testing water supplies for abortion-related substances. Others introduced liability requirements, restrictions on telehealth, or special medical-waste collection procedures.

The political strategy is noteworthy because it shifts the conversation. Instead of asking whether the government should restrict abortion, lawmakers can frame the issue around protecting drinking water and preventing environmental contamination.

Those are goals almost everyone supports.

But attaching a popular environmental objective to a controversial medical restriction doesn't automatically establish that the restriction is justified.

The scientific evidence still matters. The proportionality of the proposed response still matters. And the consequences for patients still matter.

If policymakers genuinely believe medication abortion creates an environmental hazard, they should produce credible evidence, quantify the risk, and explain why the proposed collection procedures are the most effective solution.

Until then, skepticism is not only appropriate. It's necessary.

How Much Government Do We Really Want in Our Bathrooms?

I keep returning to one particularly uncomfortable aspect of this controversy.

The intimate nature of the proposed requirements.

We're accustomed to governments regulating medications, healthcare facilities, sanitation systems, and the handling of hazardous medical waste.

Those responsibilities can serve legitimate public purposes.

But this legislation reaches into a very different setting.

A woman's home.

Her bathroom.

A private medical event that may involve bleeding, pain, fear, relief, sadness, or some complicated combination of emotions.

And in the middle of that experience, lawmakers want a standardized collection system.

I wonder how many people supporting this proposal have seriously considered what compliance would look like for an actual patient.

What happens when someone cannot identify the material they're supposed to collect? What happens when the pregnancy is extremely early? What happens when the patient is experiencing significant pain or bleeding? What happens when the nearest provider willing to accept the material is hours away?

And perhaps most importantly, what happens when the process itself causes unnecessary emotional distress?

These are not insignificant details to be sorted out later.

They're central to whether the proposed policy makes sense in the first place.

The Most Disturbing Part Isn't the Kit

As of November 13, 2026, the Don't Flush Babies Act is proposed federal legislation, not an enacted nationwide requirement. It was referred to the House Committee on Energy and Commerce after its introduction.

Women are not suddenly required under this bill to collect pregnancy tissue in brightly colored containers.

That distinction deserves emphasis because there is no reason to manufacture a crisis when the actual legislative proposal is sufficiently alarming on its own.

What concerns me most isn't simply the existence of a Catch Kit.

It's the precedent behind it.

If lawmakers can use disputed environmental claims to justify elaborate new restrictions on medication abortion, what other private healthcare decisions might eventually become subject to similar requirements?

And if the government can dictate how pregnancy tissue must be collected, labeled, transported, and disposed of after an abortion, where exactly does that regulatory authority end?

People can disagree passionately about abortion. They can believe that fetal remains deserve special treatment. They can support environmental protections and insist that medical waste be handled responsibly.

Those positions don't eliminate the need to ask whether a proposed law is scientifically justified, medically appropriate, practical, and respectful of patients.

Because ultimately, this debate isn't just about abortion pills or wastewater.

It's about how much control government should exercise over intimate medical decisions, and how easily that control can be expanded through regulations that sound perfectly reasonable until someone explains what they actually require.

We've reached a peculiar moment in American politics when Congress is debating whether women should be equipped with biohazard containers to collect the biological remains of their own pregnancies.

And the lawmakers promoting the idea have given it an almost cheerful little name.

A Catch Kit.

Somehow, I doubt the women expected to use one will find anything cheerful about it.

Abortion
Abortion Laws
Health
Comment
React
Play
Menu
avatar
Written by
5 Followers
Following 2
B.A. in English & M.A. in Journalism. Managing Editor of Bouncin & Behavin Pubs on Medium. I'm here 24/7 to help you. I write about life.